In a truly bizarre case, one New York City police department officer is suing the city as a result of the actions of another officer.
In 2011 NYPD Detective Joseph Oquendo fell asleep in his BMW at a traffic light. As Oquendo slept, police and EMT professionals arrived on the scene. After sleeping for more than 10 minutes Detective Oquendo was awakened when an officer knocked on the window of his car. Noting that there was an open beer can in the car at the time, Oquendo was arrested on suspicion of DUI.
In the police report which was filed about the incident, NYPD sergeant Viet Cao wrote that he had found Oquendo "slumped over the steering wheel" upon arriving on the scene, and that he had knocked for several minutes on the windshield before Oquendo finally awakened. Cao also said that Detective Oquendo needed to support himself against his car in order to stand up. All of these statements were contradicted by video of the incident which was captured by a local surveillance camera. Oquendo was subsequently acquitted of all charges.
As a result of what he considers a false arrest, Oquendo is now suing the city of New York for over $2 million. Though the case has yet to go to trial, if the city is forced to pay out as a result of the incident, it will not be the first time Cao's actions cost the city money. In 2013 Cao arrested a film student who he believed was filming an NYPD precinct building, though filming a public building is not illegal. The student filed suit against the NYPD, which was later settled for an undisclosed amount.
Unfortunately, this type of behavior on the part of police officers (i.e., lying about the facts leading to an arrest) happens regularly. The sworn statements of a lying police officer are difficult to overcome. In this particular case, Detective Oquendo was lucky to have the benefit of a video recording of the incident. Exposing the lies of a law enforcement officer takes experience and skill in the art of cross examination.
Have you been charged with a criminal offense in New York City? Our premier criminal defense firm has a proven track record of successful cases and we know what it takes to get results. Our NYC criminal defense lawyer is an experienced litigator with extensive trial and courtroom experience.